Played this for the first time tonight, it was a big success and we both really enjoyed it. A few comments though that would improve it for us...
Some of the talky bits at the start will probably get quite stale pretty quickly, especially of you get the same ones repeatedly. I'm not sure how you avoid this though without giving the option to skip them and there are certainly some there that would bring is together. I think it's a good thing that the game has this aspect to help us understand each other's likes and dislikes.
Not being religious, and certainly not Christian, the bible references are a bit of a turn off for us from an otherwise superb game. No offence intended to your personal beliefs but can we remove them with the action editor?